Frame 1 - Sharmila visits Dharmendra's family house
and is asked by his sister to take him a cup of chai. For
the first time she is introduced to Dharmendra's environment.
She silently brings him the tea. Dharmendra is so immersed
in his writing he is unaware of her presence. The camera is
watching and does not represent the point of view of either
character but observes how the characters interact from a
'fourth wall' perspective.
Frame 2 - Dharmendra realizes that Sharmila is
there and begins to tell her about the story he is writing.
He holds the manuscript between them. This is the third character
in the relationship, that of the story Dharmendra is writing
about/for Sharmila, the camera reflects this by placing it
between them. The camera watches both characters equally in
the same frame. The elements of the film techniques of point
of view and shot - reverse shot are not present, instead the
camera chooses to view the scene from the theatrical fourth
wall of the audience.
Frame 3 - Dharmendra narrates the story he his
writing to Sharmila and she listens. The characters no longer
look at each other but to opposite sides of the frame at nothing
in particular. If they see anything at all, it is the words
that Dharmendra is speaking. At this point both of the characters
visual point of view has dissolved completely. The way the
shot is staged illustrates and reinforces this conceit. Sharmila's
character has now transcended into the realm of imagination.
Frame 4 -This could be considered the antithesis
of a point of view shot. Dharmendra continues to narrate his
story. Dharmendra has not changed position from where he is
viewed in frame 3, it is the camera that has changed position.
Sharmila was not even looking in his direction when the camera
changed shots. The implications of this shot have nothing
to do with the very direct visual language talked about in
the first example on page 1. The meaning of this shot is symbolic
and metaphoric. Behind Dharmendra's right is a portrait of
the Indian poet Rabindranath Tagore symbolic of the transformative
power of words. Behind Dharmendra's left is a window to the
outside, symbolic of liberation. In Dharmendra's hands at
the bottom of the frame is his manuscript that is the catalyst
for change. The shot is like an altar with symbols representing
the films offerings to Sharmila.
Sharmila's character evolves in the course of "Anupama".
Director Hrishikesh Mukherjee and cinematographer Jaywant
Pathare subtly illustrate this transformation through sophisticated
manipulation of filmic techniques, a few of which I've given
example of here.
*(As movie trivia asides, "Anupama" was nominated
for 'Film of the Year' at the 1966 Filmfare Awards, the award
though went to Vijay Anand's "Guide". Jaywant Pathare
won the Filmfare Award the same year for his cinematography
for "Anupama". It is interesting that the Bengali
writer Rabindranath Tagore is on the wall of Dharmendra's
room. Sharmila Tagore, the main character of "Anupama"
comes from the same family and is directly related to the
Nobel Prize winning poet.)