1) - In a career that spanned over 30 years Manmohan Desai wrote,
directed, or produced over 40 films and is ranked as one of the all
time great film makers of Bollywood. It is often said of Desai that
his film's story lines cared little for logic and that he was more concerned
with bringing entertainment to the masses. This claim was and is a pretty
fair assessment, however this secondary concern for logic was not from
any lack of film making expertise on Desai's part. It was a stylistic
device used by him to forward a more main concern for comedic or dramatic
interaction within entertaining situations. Desai was what I would term,
a 'situationist', he had an innate imagination and talent for putting
his characters into situations that would make his audience laugh, cry,
or cheer. Very often the situation was absurd or ironic and involved
the use of disguises, mistaken identity, or (as became his trademark)
the 'lost and found' story. Consequently in order to get his characters
into these inspired situations very often logic was thrown to the wind.
But Desai knew, that everybody knew, that his stories were not about
logic, they were about the magic of imagination and what could be.
Desai's main "situation" his character's found themselves
in was what has become known as the 'Lost and Found' story. This usually
consisted of brother's separated at birth who grow up nurturing opposing
ideologies (one rich, one poor, or one Hindu and the other Muslim) but
because of destiny driven situations they are reunited and learn their
true identities. The brother's reconcile their differences and usually
bring order back to the community in the process. It is a conceit that
anyone could identify with regardless of geographical borders, religious
beliefs, age group, or any other type of dividing factor. This brings
us to another theme inherit in the films of Manmohan Desai and that
is the unity of Indians regardless of geographies, class, or religion.
He is very much remembered as a film maker who put forth stories that
asked his audience to look beyond social differences and instead at
human commonalties .